In a verdict that will benefit thousands of land owners, the Delhi high court on Wednesday allowed registration of properties even if they are valued below the minimum circle rate of the area. Till now, if the valuation of a property was lower than the prevailing circle rate, the registrar summarily rejected it. A bench of Chief Justice G Rohini and Justice R S Endlaw relied on provisions of the Indian Stamp Act to revive discretionary powers vested with the state government under Section 47A to register sale of property below the local circle rate.
Property owners will have an opportunity to convince the Collector of Stamps why their asset should be valued below the circle rate of the area. The registrarsub registrar will accept such saleconveyance deeds and forward it to the Collector of Stamps before whom property owners can make their case. The HC recognized that there may be various reasons for low valuation, such as a property being disputed, having unauthorized occupants, poor location etc. According to Section 47A of the Indian Stamp Act, which was cited by the HC, “If the registering officer while registering any instrument transferring any property , has reason to believe that the value of the property or the consideration, as the case may be has not been truly set forth in the instrument, he may , after registering such instrument, refer the same to Collector for determination of the value and proper duty payable.“
It also empowers the Collector to give a chance to the owner to give an explanation, and then conduct an independent inquiry before determining the actual worth of the property .
The HC made it clear that circle rate circulars issued by Delhi government from time to time since 2007 can no longer come in the way of registration of a property . Its directions came on a bunch of PILs filed by Manu Narang, Amit Gupta and Atul Gupta arguing that “no absolute benchmark can be fixed and dictated for determination of the minimum price of any property since prices of property vary from place to place, person to person and due to various other factors.“
The PILs challenged Delhi government’s circulars issued from 2007 till 2014 hiking circle rates after every revision.
Source: Times of India
Dated: 24th December 2015